Reader Interactions


  1. Susie

    This looks great….. I love lemon I'm going to have to make this even if no one else in the house likes lemon they are on their own. 🙂

  2. Anne

    Oh my goodness… I just made my first lemon cream pie, and this looks just as delicious (with the creaminess mixed in)! Definitely going on my to-do list.

    Oh, and I almost never bake anything more than once either – if I can't get a post out of it I usually can't be bothered! But there are a few faves (pumpkin pie, banana bread) that are constantly rotated behind the scenes…

  3. Chef Dennis

    what a gorgeous pie! I love how the crust comes up higher it really looks great! I bet really delicious too, I do love lemon anything and that creamy dessert is right up my alley!

  4. Sasha @ The Procrastobaker

    This really does looks absolutely excellent, and its sliced so perfectly! If i did that it would be a broken up crumby mess, but delicious non-the less im sure by the sounds of that yummy recipe 🙂 In a lemon loving household such as this im pretty sure this would go down a storrmmm. Gorgeous photos too!

  5. Wendy (The Weekend Gourmet)

    I love lemon anything…it just screams SUMMER to me! This looks wonderful…if you want to add some really good lemon bars to your bag of tricks, come by my blog. I posted one earlier this week from Secret Recipe Swap that was really fantastic!!

  6. Lucy

    This pie is stunning – the golden crumbly crust looks so delicious! Love the look of the deep creamy filling too – I adore anything lemony.

  7. Cam

    Just wondering, is it necessary to freeze the pie? I'd love to try making this for a dinner coming up soon but my freezer is chock-full!

  8. Dimi

    Hi, I just wanted to ask, would it make any difference if I didn't use as many egg yolks but instead used 4 whole eggs? I'm not much of an egg fan and I always try to put less in every recipe I make xD

  9. Jose

    Hello LEMON lovers! aaaaaaaaahh i'm so glad everybody feels the same way about lemon pies. Oh gosh I wish I could just reach in and grab and it eat. Thanks for the post I think I will continue to bake more lemon pies.

  10. mmedow

    Oh My !!! What a Pie !! My favourite flavour in all the world….I can taste it right now without yet eating it ! Thank you for the post…always looking for new ways with lemon…..

  11. nana5

    I made this and it brings back childhood memories my mom use to make this every sunday, I finally found the right recipe. Love It

  12. Lydia

    Hey! It seems weird to be commenting on this post two years late, but I just wanted to say thank you for this fantastic recipe! I found it on Pinterest and it's become one of my favorites! I'm making it for the fourth or fifth time tonight 🙂

  13. Megan Porta

    Hi Lydia! I'm so glad you enjoy this recipe so much! It's one of our faves, too. Total deliciousness. 🙂

  14. Megan Porta

    JDL: Freezing the pie is necessary, and you will understand when you make it. It comes out deliciously cold and perfect! Hope this helps! 🙂

  15. Lynn

    If you can find Nabisco’s "Original"Graham Crackers,it will make a much better crust than the Honey Grahams. The "Original has a much better graham taste. I found a box of them in a Big Lots store and they were exactly how I remembered them as a child.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *